Yet another version to this concern, which is clearly one of the most frequently asked on Quora:
Why does the US give ‘financial backing’ for Israel?
The US federal government has actually decided that spending in excess of $120 billion annually to promote its geopolitical goals is worth it. And the $3 billion of credits that is provided to Israel versus purchase of US military hardware is chump change compared to what it actually invests in other allies.
David Vine, a professor at American University, mentions in Base Nation: How U.S. Military Bases Abroad Harm America and the World that there are 150,500 American troops stationed in seventy nations around the world. The cost quote to the American taxpayer yearly is at least $85-100 billion. When the genuine expenses are computed, the largest aid recipient is Japan, where 48,828 US military personnel are stationed. This translates into an US military aid bundle of over $27 billion. Germany, with 37,704 US troops on its soil, gets help comparable to around $21 billion; South Korea, with 27,553 US soldiers, receives over $15 billion; and Italy receives a minimum of $6 billion.
What does the US government get from those credits?
While the Israel-haters wish to present the United States military aid package as some type of ‘no strings attached’ gift, the reality is more of an exchange of goods and services, as well as the fulfillment of pledges made by the United States in peace treaties.
Containment of Soviet/Russian Impact
One informing point is that the United States did not support Israel militarily till after 1967, and financially possibly not up until the 1980’s. The Cold War dominated United States geopolitics, spurring limitless operations to consist of Soviet influence in nearly every corner of the globe. Only when Israel showed itself as a beneficial foe to the Soviet client states that surrounded it in 1967 did the US support begin.Although the Cold War is over, in many methods the US habits towards Russia is similar to that of the USSR. In the following chart, note how the nations who get the most US aid are adjacent to Russia and her allies (Syria, Iran, Hizbullah).
An US warship in a troubled area
Israel exists in a highly tactical and yet highly unstable region. And even the most ardent Israel-hater should agree that Israel can be counted on as a trusted United States ally. United States Secretary of State Alexander Haig compared Israel to “the biggest American carrier in the world that can not be sunk, does not carry even one American soldier, and is located in an important area for American nationwide security.” It might be included that this ‘aircraft carrier’ does not cost almost as much as the drifting range (carriers are hugely pricey to develop and preserve). It could and perhaps ought to also be noted that the United States does now operate an extremely small base in Israel, with about 100 workers. Israel philosophically discovers it distasteful to have a foreign base on its soil, however the size and advantages of this mini-base sufficed for it to make this one exception.
The expense of keeping an US military existence in Germany and Japan, really wealthy countries which exist in much less volatile or tactical areas, is approximated to cost US taxpayers at least $20 billion each year for each nation. Israel is rather a deal in comparison.
Balance of military help
US provides economic and military help to numerous countries who exhibit lukewarm acceptance of Israel’s presence if not outright hostility. Israel’s instant next-door neighbors figure large on the list of US help, as do the horror centers of Pakistan and Afghanistan. The Camp David Accords, which supplies lots of geopolitical advantages to the United States, guaranteed Egypt considerable economic and military aid. If one wants to be seen as fair and balanced, equal support should be offered to both sides.
Moreover, US has sold advanced military hardware worth 10s of billions of dollars to rich Arab petro-states who have routinely demanded Israel’s damage in the past. If you want to make the sale and yet keep Israel as an ally, you need to offer some reciprocity.
Increase domestic defense market
With brand-new Obama policies, 100%of United States help to Israel is spent on purchasing equipment from the US. This is definitely in contrast to US military costs in Germany and Japan, for example. In those countries much of the military budget is spent in your area, aiding the local economy a lot more than that of the United States.
Control of the sale of Israeli weapons to US competitors
Israeli high tech weaponry is valued throughout the world, and sought after by numerous nations, consisting of some which are not exactly friendly to United States interests. To apply this particular impact over Israel, which likewise impacts Israeli GDP, some reward must be offered by the US.
A recent Trump scandal in the last few months exposed a little the dependence of the United States intelligence community on the Mossad. Trump revealed to Russia some information of a Mossad operation where Israeli agents permeated Islamic State and discovered their plan to plant bombs in laptop computers taken onboard business aircraft bound for the United States.
It is clear that the US counts on Mossad for access to vital information, and this has actually held true for decades. George Keagan, former head of U.S. Air Force Intelligence, stated that “Israel is worth five CIAs.”
Application to a recent news product: when an Israeli F16 was shot down by a barrage of Syrian anti-aircraft missiles, the information of that conflict is of substantial significance to the US armed force. The US can anticipate to get extensive information that will help plan future possible interactions with Russian industrialized systems.
Joint military hardware advancement
Israel has an unique position in its cooperation with the US on advancement of military hardware. Many projects, such as the Arrow rocket, are established together to the benefit and expense savings of both.
Additionally, Israel is a considerable test bed for United States military hardware. It was primarily Israeli-flown but US-built F-15 fighter jets that accrued the F-15’s enviable record.
” The first kill by an F-15 was scored by Israeli Air Force ace Moshe Melnik in 1979. … F-15 As reportedly downed 13 Syrian MiG-21 s and 2 Syrian MiG-25 s. Israeli F-15 As and Bs got involved as escorts in Operation Opera, an air strike on an Iraqi atomic power plant In the 1982 Lebanon War, Israeli F-15 s were credited with 41 Syrian airplane damaged (23 MiG-21 s and 17 MiG-23 s, and one Aérospatiale SA.342 L Gazelle helicopter). Throughout Operation Mole Cricket 19, Israeli F-15 s and F-16 s together shot down 82 Syrian fighter airplane (MiG-21 s, MiG-23 s, and MiG-23 Ms) with no losses.
Moreover, much info about the latest Soviet technologies were gotten during Israel’s lots of wars to defend its existence.
Israel is the only genuinely reputable area in the area for the storage of United States military hardware if US required to get that product to a close-by theatre of operation quickly.
Protecting Shipping Lanes
Perhaps one of the most crucial roles for the sole international superpower is to preserve the safety of the world’s shipping lanes. Much of what can be stated in praise of Pax Romana and Pax Britannia was their defense of trade routes, and the increase in worldwide wealth since of that. In this regard, Israel is a great assistance to the US, considering its area near to the Horn of Africa and one of the most notorious shipping traffic jams accessed by Somali pirates.
Supreme AIPAC lobbyists?
In spite of all of this, Israel haters enjoy to single out AIPAC as having enormous impact in Washington. Although it is clear that AIPAC is barely the most effective lobby for a foreign country in Washington, we might also seek to the success of AIPAC in lobbying congress to vote versus Obama’s Iran deal. AIPAC stopped working totally. Omnipotent? Maybe not.
Here is a list of the funding of foreign lobbyists:
” In 2010, foreign federal governments spent around $460 million on lobbying Congress and the U.S. Government In Between 2015–2017, the Saudi Arabia paid $18 million to 145 registered lobbyists to affect the U.S. federal government.”
Where is the outrage about South Korea and Japan, who invest far more than Israel in lobbying the US government?
However even foreign nations fade in comparison to the top lobbyist groups: